Monday, December 5, 2011

Food for Thought When Hiring a Divorce Lawyer

I have the opportunity to work with many talented lawyers and their clients.  It is truly a privilege to have people put their trust in me to help them resolve the most important issues they face.  This article from The Huffington Post gives good advice to clients who are seeking divorce counsel and dispels the myth that the meanest divorce lawyer is necessarily the most effective.  As with all relationships, the key to the attorney/client relationship is trust – the client must trust the attorney has their best interests in view.  As a mediator, I strive to build trust with both clients and attorneys from the outset so we can reach the best and most effective result.   The advice here is practical and should be heeded by anyone who has to hire divorce counsel.

Thursday, October 20, 2011

Mediation Week - Continued

As I posted earlier this week, the American Bar Association has desgnated this week "Mediation Week."  Here in Alabama, Governor Bentley has proclaimed tomorrow "Mediation Day in Alabama."  Thanks to the Birmingham News for publishing my article this morning on the benefits of mediation.  A link to the article follows:

http://blog.al.com/businessnews/2011/10/memorandum_mediation_offers_a.html

Monday, October 17, 2011

So it is "Mediation Week" - Why Should We Care?

The American Bar Association has designated the week of October 16-22, 2011 as national “Mediation Week.” Governor Robert Bentley signed a Proclamation declaring October 21, 2011 as “Mediation Day” across the State of Alabama.  So what?  Why should Alabama businesses and consumers care about such things?
They should care because mediation provides them a more cost-effective, time efficient and comprehensive way to resolve disputes than litigation.  According to the Alabama Administrative Office of Courts, last year over 37,000 civil cases and 5,000 divorce related cases were filed in Jefferson County. This does not include the backlog of already pending cases. With State court cutbacks and the never-ending battle over Jefferson County’s finances, the court system in Jefferson County is bursting at the seams. The costs for litigation increase as cases have to wait longer for trial dates – not to mention the increased stress on the parties as their disputes drag on. Mediation provides a better path to resolution.

So how does mediation work? The mediator (a neutral third party) provides a forum for open communication and guides the parties’ negotiations so that they reach an informed and mutually acceptable result to their dispute.  By agreeing to mediate, the parties use their intimate knowledge of the situation to reach a solution that is tailored to their needs.  Advantages of mediation:
-    A “win-win” for the participants – not a decision by a judge or jury
-    Less expensive than litigation
-    Promotes continued relationships
-    Moves more quickly than litigation – and usually with less stress
-    Confidentiality—no public record
-    Scheduled to the convenience of the parties
-    Clarity and mutual understanding of the results achieved

Mediation is a very effective tool for resolving:

-    Civil lawsuits - including personal injury claims, consumer disputes, breach of contract, fraud claims and other similar matters
-    Family law disputes such as divorce, child custody and support issues
-    Estate, probate and elder care disputes
-    Employment disputes
-    Business-related disputes
-    Disputes between neighbors or within a community

Mediation is not arbitration, nor is it a trial. The mediator is not making a decision for the disputing parties.  The mediator guides the parties to reach their own decision, and promotes respect and dignity for all participants.  Statistics show that when parties to a dispute actively participate in crafting its resolution, they are more satisfied with the outcome and are more likely to abide by its terms.  Mediation truly provides a win-win for the participants.

Difficult times require creative solutions. I am encouraged by the efforts of the ABA and Governor Bentley in promoting mediation.  The public needs to know that there are more civil, more cost effective, faster and less destructive ways to resolve disputes than lengthy litigation.  Mediation gives the people involved a chance to shape a resolution that fits their specific needs in a creative and constructive way, with neither side ending up on the wrong side of a judgment.  I hope the people of Alabama take the time to explore their options before racing to the courthouse.

Thursday, October 6, 2011

Great Quote and Goal for Life

Life is not a series of accidents.  It is a collection of purposeful acts and decisions that we make.  When we choose to be purposeful in our commitment to using our individual powers for the advancement of the collective good, then we are in search of the sacred.  When we purposefully strive to live our lives in accordance with the highest universal values, then we merge with the sacred.  When we give over our lives to the calling of healing, justice and love, then we bring sacredness to the lives of others and to the world.

David Hall, LLM, JD, from “In Search of the Sacred,” The Collaborative Review, Winter 2005, p.29.

Tuesday, September 20, 2011

Collaborative Law Comes to Alabama – FINALLY!

What a privilege it was to participate in the first ever interdisciplinary collaborative law training in Alabama!  This past weekend, approximately 40 like-minded professionals from the worlds of law, mental health and finance came together to learn how we could work together in teams to make the process of getting divorced less destructive, more dignified and respectful, and tailored to the needs of the family going through it - because marriages may end, but families do not.

Collaborative law is a process in which the parties to a divorce hire lawyers and other appropriate professionals trained in collaborative practice to negotiate a resolution of their divorce.  The parties agree that a lawsuit will not be filed and that all exchanges of information will be voluntary and completely transparent.  In order to ensure that the negotiation process is followed, the parties not only agree to voluntary participation, but they along with their lawyers and other team members agree that if the process fails, the lawyers will not represent the clients in an adversarial proceeding.  The theory is that if everyone agrees to the process, and knows going in that litigation cannot happen (at least with their collaborative lawyers and team professionals), the incentive to negotiate and treat each other fairly will lead to an acceptable resolution.  The process allows for other “nonparty participants” to be part of the process – financial professionals, divorce coaches, child specialists (collectively with the lawyers “the collaborative team”) – to help the parties address their individual needs and concerns, the needs of their children, and to shape the appropriate agreement to address those needs.  The process is privileged and confidential and the communications made during the process cannot be later introduced in a trial.

We had a top notch training staff, including the women who literally wrote the book (“Collaborative Divorce” HarperCollins Publishers, 2006), Pauline H. Tesler, M.A., J.D., and Peggy Thompson, Ph.D.  Joining Pauline and Peggy was Lisa Schneider, CFP, CDFA – a long time regular member of their collaborative teams from the San Francisco Bay Area.  The three days we spent with our trainers were equal parts challenging and invigorating.  I hope I speak for the entire group when I say we walked away with no doubts that the collaborative model is the healthiest, most equitable, and one of the most cost effective ways a family can traverse the minefield of divorce.

There are over 20,000 trained collaborative professionals practicing in at least 19 countries worldwide.  This model has been adopted, approved and promoted by numerous judges, state appellate court justices and bar associations around the U.S.  Here in Alabama, Robert E. Lusk, Jr., assistant General Counsel to the Alabama State Bar Association, has confirmed for us that collaborative law is alive and well in Alabama and in full compliance with the Rules of Professional Conduct (note to those lawyers who still want to question whether collaborative agreements are ethical – this should allay your concerns.  Please feel free to call the Bar if you have questions about the ethicality of this process).  Further, the National Conference of Commissioners on Uniform State Laws has promulgated the Uniform Collaborative Law Act, which has been proposed in the Alabama Legislature by Senator Cam Ward.

The process just makes sense.  Lawyers are freed up from trying to wear every hat to focus on what they are trained to do best – address legal issues.  Divorce coaches and child specialists, who are trained mental health professionals, help the parties address the emotional and decision making needs and insure that the children have a well trained voice in the process that is all their own.  A neutral financial professional gathers the data related to assets, debts, expenses and the like, and presents a neutral picture of the marital estate so that everyone is working from the same – and most importantly accurate – picture of the family’s financial position.  That same neutral financial professional also helps everyone understand the financial implications of the decisions the parties are making under however many scenarios the parties want to look at.  The end result is an agreement that addresses the needs of the entire family that the parties themselves have created with the assistance of the proper professionals – and those professionals remain available to the family after the divorce as they transition into the next stages of life. 

Common questions come up when discussing collaborative law: How can a process involving all those professionals be cost effective?  Won’t the process take forever with all those professionals in the mix?  The answers are fairly easy.

First, clients are not paying lawyers (typically the highest hourly rates on the “team”) to try to be financial professionals digesting and explaining the complexities of finances.  Nor are clients paying their lawyers’ hourly rates to address every anger or emotional issue that arises – and lawyers are inherently the wrong professionals to bring these types of concerns to anyway (we typically, although not always intentionally, end up throwing gasoline on the fire).  Further, clients are not asking lawyers to make their best guess at what is the proper role for each parent with their children after the divorce. 

Also, clients are not paying for multiple trips to the courthouse for their lawyers to attend hearings or try the case.  On any given day in Birmingham, there are approximately 2,500 divorce cases pending and those cases take on average anywhere from a year to eighteen months to reach trial.  Comparatively, the collaborative process will typically take a matter of a few months to reach resolution.  The biggest plus of collaborative law is that clients are not leaving the most important matters in their life - the involvement of each parent with their children and how post-divorce financial issues will be handled - to a well-intentioned complete stranger (the trial judge) who listens to a few hours of testimony and makes his or her best efforts to make those decisions for them.  The clients make fully informed decisions for themselves.

The process takes less time than it takes to go to trial or settle your case on the courthouse steps, and the time that is spent is divided between various professionals at hourly rates that are appropriate to their professions.  The process is quicker and less expensive than litigation and nowhere near as destructive.

Collaborative law promotes dignity and respect.  It is tailored to the family in question.  It is fair.  It is confidential.  It is transparent. It is cost effective. It is time effective.  It works.  I look forward to watching this model take hold in Alabama and am proud to call myself a collaborative professional.


For more information on collaborative law, please check out the following sources:




Friday, September 9, 2011

Birmingham Bar ADR Seminar – an Update from the Bench

I participated in a panel discussion yesterday at the Birmingham Bar Center regarding how ADR can help ease the backlog of cases currently facing all divisions of our courts in Jefferson County.  I was honored to be on this panel with our presiding judge, Scott Vowell, criminal judge Stephen Wallace, domestic relations judge Julie Palmer, mediator John Hall, and attorney Anthony Joseph.   I send out a special thank you to Michael Trucks for thinking of me to fill his slot on this panel when he became unavailable to participate.  I appreciate any opportunity to speak about ADR issues as I believe strongly in the process and am committed to spreading the message.

A number of topics related to ADR and the courts were presented to a group of about 35 lawyers in attendance.  An overriding theme was the current cutbacks our courts face.  The numbers of cases stuck in the system is staggering – in the domestic relations (divorce) courts alone on any given day there are approximately 2,500 cases pending, and many stay in the system for a year to 18 months or longer!  Mediation can help move cases through the system – while providing better results for the parties in a cost effective manner.   Spreading the word is the key.

We discussed a number of great ADR programs working in our courts – volunteer mediation dockets in district civil and domestic relations courts, pro bono mediation available in circuit court, proposals for mediation in criminal cases, work with the Birmingham Volunteer Lawyers Program, the Cumberland School of Law Community Mediation Center and its program for mediating college support cases at the Jefferson County Family Court, and the upcoming Collaborative Law training.  Birmingham has a very diverse and vibrant ADR community.  Our ADR section of the Birmingham Bar is doing a great job to spread the word that better alternatives are out there.   I am committed to doing my part – and I hope the legal community will take greater advantage of the resources available to help ease the burden on our courts during this time of budgetary cut-backs.

Thursday, August 25, 2011

Focus on the Decision Maker - Not on the Deal

This article is a great reminder of where the focus in mediation needs to be.  I've never been a fan of pushing mediation sessions late into the night just to "get it done today" or "strike a deal while we have everyone at the table." Decision makers need to pace themselves to make the best decisions - not be put in a position of late day fatigue that leads to a rushed decision.

http://www.nytimes.com/2011/08/21/magazine/do-you-suffer-from-decision-fatigue.html?pagewanted=1&_r=1